Some favorites and very few duds from Friday's commenting.
Favorites, in no particular order:
dont-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac, Hatey McLife, and SponsoredbyV8 played an awesome game of kick-the-can in the Kids And Their Dunks thread. I love to see commenters riffing on each other's stuff. cheese mac had another gem in the Manny Ramirez thread.
And those are the only favorites for what was a graveyard of a day in Deadspin commenting.
Total Fucking Duds:
Deadspin I-Team posts are often especially terrible, because many people seem to think that the appeal for information somehow lifts the requirement that comments be funny. Friday's I-Team post was no exception. Unstarred commenters ScarletSquire and BarbarobicsInstructor did their part to reinforce the common perception of Deadspin's comment threads as safe places for ignorant, obnoxious, borderline-offensive bullshit, with this and this, respectively. Boo on them both.
Also, unstarred commenter HelenaHandbasket earned a mention for an utter failure to simply read the rest of the Manny Ramirez thread before dropping this turd in it. This comment would not be funny even if it was remotely original, and it is not remotely original.
All in all, Friday was a pretty rotten day for commenting, which is consistent with my general sense that Fridays are a weak day for commenting.
Happy weekend DUANs. See you on Monday.
Saturday, April 9, 2011
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Thursday Roundup
Some favorites and very few duds from Thursday's commenting.
Favorites, in no particular order:
Our boy Gamboa Constrictor got things started this morning with a humdinger in the Wake Up Deadspin post, a clever reworking of a reference to a recent Deadspin item, earning high praise from his peers.
Steve U got in on the act in the same post with another hilarious dig at Tony LaRussa's apparent alcoholism. Honestly, I could read well-made Larussa-as-a-drunk jokes all day.
Recent MBA punching bag ToddReesingsTurfFacial received some deserved applause for a well-crafted, confidently delivered language joke in the Gloria James post. It's nice to see him tone down the shtick and offer a grown-up-sounding comment. Good job.
I chuckled aloud at David Hume's dig at Albert Pujols in the Gloria James post. Simple, straightforward, deadpan, terrific.
Vodkanaut delivered a characteristically silly, off-beat, out-of-left-field movie reference in the Backflip Penalty Kick post, and I loved it. One liners are great, but frankly, if the Deadspin comments section were all one-liners, it wouldn't be nearly as interesting. The long-form jokes reveal a sophistication in the commentariat that makes it all the more impressive. Great job here.
Also in the Backflip Penalty Kick post, SponsoredbyV8 checked in with a beautifully simple one-word joke with a subtle punchline. This joke didn't get nearly the attention it deserved.
Hatey McLife's vicious one-liner in the Fried Food post was good for a guilty laugh. The slightest mistake in delivery here would have made this comment ugly and obnoxious, but that's why Hatey's Hatey.
All Over But The Sharting's clever two-part comment in the Masters Photo post was good for . . . well, two separate chuckles. The first part was good enough, and then it looks like he had another moment of inspiration, and was able to expand upon the original joke. Nice job.
EddieSutton's SouthernComfort delivered another wonderfully elegant joke, also in the Masters Photo post, and earned a round of applause for his efforts. That's a perfect comment.
Also in the Masters Photo post, unstarred commenter snoop-a-loop delivered a hilarious contribution in the same vein as ESSC's, earning a promotion and some positive feedback. The commentariat really showed up for this post today.
Deadspin veteran Karlifornia slayed me with his vulgar A League of Their Own reference, in the Softball Mea Culpa post. Once upon a time, Karlifornia was a Commenter of the Year runner up, but he's been mostly out of action for a long while now.
And finally, reigning champ Eddie Murray Sparkles cracked me up big-time with his observation of the photo from the Ray Allen Interview post. I laughed and laughed at this.
Total Fucking Duds:
ToddReesingsTurfFacial had a rare two-fer today, showing up in both the Favorites and the Duds. His comment in the Masters Photo post was sufficiently lame and uninspired to earn a gray-job from the powers-that-be. It's one thing for an unstarred doofus to offer a totally lifeless low-hanging-fruit movie reference, but featured commenters really ought to know better. And furthermore, shifting gears and including your back-up joke in the same comment is just clumsy and desperate. This is the problem with grinding; you can't pump out 1-3 comments per post without fairly often just throwing up the first thought that comes to mind and hitting submit. If the unedited, unrefined thought isn't funny enough all by itself, it will be a bad comment. This was a bad comment.
In the Softball Mea Culpa post, Phintastic had nothing to offer beyond a clumsily reworked and utterly irrelevant movie quote from Pulp Fiction. I don't have anything against a reworked quote or lyric or title; in fact, I am a huge sucker for that kind of joke. But there is no tie-in or relevance to this comment, other than that the guy's name is Paul. Again, as with Phin's bad comment from . . . the other day, that's just way too flimsy a pretext for the joke. The name Paul is not funny or interesting or uncommon enough to justify it's use as the centerpiece of a comment, and I find it very hard to believe even Phintastic would disagree. In Pulp Fiction, the line "my name's Paul, and this shit's between y'all" is used by a glorified extra to get out of a sticky conversation. The way Phintastic reworked it, it doesn't even make sense: "his name's Paul, and this is between us all" implies that we, the readers, are somehow involved. If he'd made it a quote from Paul, it still wouldn't be funny at all, but it would at least make sense.
I suppose there's a bit of a paradox I should address regarding grinding and lazy commenting and the need to finesse one's comments before submitting them. Namely, that even a funny idea needs to be carefully constructed in order to make a good comment from it, and how that may work opposite the abilities or available time and energy of many or most commenters. For example, say you're an unstarred commenter, and you open a post, read it, and have a glimmer of inspiration. The clock is ticking. The idea seems potentially funny to you, but you can't seem to work it into a tight, elegant package. I know there's a joke here, you think. Iteration after iteration passes, but none seem to really maximize the humor of the idea. Before too long, the post is sliding down the timeline, and the window to make the comment and have anyone read it, ever, is closing. Furthermore, while you were struggling with this idea in this post, 2 or 3 new posts have come up, and now you're well behind the crowd's attention span. Following this pattern, it's possible you may never be able to get one of your good ideas down when it matters, if at all. What to do?
If you're Phintastic or ToddReesingsTurfFacial or norbizness, you say "to hell with that" and stop finessing your comments altogether, favoring the opportunity to lay down a high volume of comments over the need to finesse each individual comment to its best possible version. You are now a grinder. This is bad. Most readers just start to ignore your comments, and the only people who ever respond to them or enjoy them are newbies or other grinders.
This standard sometimes seems unfair even to me, especially when applied to someone like Phintastic; he's put in his time, he's been around the block, maybe he's earned the right to not worry so much about whether his jokes are perfected. Why should he be disallowed from engaging in the fun of a good thread because he doesn't have time to reformat what he thinks is an already-funny concept? The real problem with grinding, as I see it, is that it lowers the standard for other commenters, and soon you've got an entire sub-set throwing up unadorned movie quotes and jpegs and sloppy, low-hanging-fruit puns, and not even attempting to submit true whoppers. It seems like that's where we are nowadays, but with the comment_ninja and FAILBOT coming back to life, perhaps we'll see a reversal of this trend.
Okay, enough of that. Jesus, I really got carried away there. Goooooooo DUAN!
Favorites, in no particular order:
Our boy Gamboa Constrictor got things started this morning with a humdinger in the Wake Up Deadspin post, a clever reworking of a reference to a recent Deadspin item, earning high praise from his peers.
Steve U got in on the act in the same post with another hilarious dig at Tony LaRussa's apparent alcoholism. Honestly, I could read well-made Larussa-as-a-drunk jokes all day.
Recent MBA punching bag ToddReesingsTurfFacial received some deserved applause for a well-crafted, confidently delivered language joke in the Gloria James post. It's nice to see him tone down the shtick and offer a grown-up-sounding comment. Good job.
I chuckled aloud at David Hume's dig at Albert Pujols in the Gloria James post. Simple, straightforward, deadpan, terrific.
Vodkanaut delivered a characteristically silly, off-beat, out-of-left-field movie reference in the Backflip Penalty Kick post, and I loved it. One liners are great, but frankly, if the Deadspin comments section were all one-liners, it wouldn't be nearly as interesting. The long-form jokes reveal a sophistication in the commentariat that makes it all the more impressive. Great job here.
Also in the Backflip Penalty Kick post, SponsoredbyV8 checked in with a beautifully simple one-word joke with a subtle punchline. This joke didn't get nearly the attention it deserved.
Hatey McLife's vicious one-liner in the Fried Food post was good for a guilty laugh. The slightest mistake in delivery here would have made this comment ugly and obnoxious, but that's why Hatey's Hatey.
All Over But The Sharting's clever two-part comment in the Masters Photo post was good for . . . well, two separate chuckles. The first part was good enough, and then it looks like he had another moment of inspiration, and was able to expand upon the original joke. Nice job.
EddieSutton's SouthernComfort delivered another wonderfully elegant joke, also in the Masters Photo post, and earned a round of applause for his efforts. That's a perfect comment.
Also in the Masters Photo post, unstarred commenter snoop-a-loop delivered a hilarious contribution in the same vein as ESSC's, earning a promotion and some positive feedback. The commentariat really showed up for this post today.
Deadspin veteran Karlifornia slayed me with his vulgar A League of Their Own reference, in the Softball Mea Culpa post. Once upon a time, Karlifornia was a Commenter of the Year runner up, but he's been mostly out of action for a long while now.
And finally, reigning champ Eddie Murray Sparkles cracked me up big-time with his observation of the photo from the Ray Allen Interview post. I laughed and laughed at this.
Total Fucking Duds:
ToddReesingsTurfFacial had a rare two-fer today, showing up in both the Favorites and the Duds. His comment in the Masters Photo post was sufficiently lame and uninspired to earn a gray-job from the powers-that-be. It's one thing for an unstarred doofus to offer a totally lifeless low-hanging-fruit movie reference, but featured commenters really ought to know better. And furthermore, shifting gears and including your back-up joke in the same comment is just clumsy and desperate. This is the problem with grinding; you can't pump out 1-3 comments per post without fairly often just throwing up the first thought that comes to mind and hitting submit. If the unedited, unrefined thought isn't funny enough all by itself, it will be a bad comment. This was a bad comment.
In the Softball Mea Culpa post, Phintastic had nothing to offer beyond a clumsily reworked and utterly irrelevant movie quote from Pulp Fiction. I don't have anything against a reworked quote or lyric or title; in fact, I am a huge sucker for that kind of joke. But there is no tie-in or relevance to this comment, other than that the guy's name is Paul. Again, as with Phin's bad comment from . . . the other day, that's just way too flimsy a pretext for the joke. The name Paul is not funny or interesting or uncommon enough to justify it's use as the centerpiece of a comment, and I find it very hard to believe even Phintastic would disagree. In Pulp Fiction, the line "my name's Paul, and this shit's between y'all" is used by a glorified extra to get out of a sticky conversation. The way Phintastic reworked it, it doesn't even make sense: "his name's Paul, and this is between us all" implies that we, the readers, are somehow involved. If he'd made it a quote from Paul, it still wouldn't be funny at all, but it would at least make sense.
I suppose there's a bit of a paradox I should address regarding grinding and lazy commenting and the need to finesse one's comments before submitting them. Namely, that even a funny idea needs to be carefully constructed in order to make a good comment from it, and how that may work opposite the abilities or available time and energy of many or most commenters. For example, say you're an unstarred commenter, and you open a post, read it, and have a glimmer of inspiration. The clock is ticking. The idea seems potentially funny to you, but you can't seem to work it into a tight, elegant package. I know there's a joke here, you think. Iteration after iteration passes, but none seem to really maximize the humor of the idea. Before too long, the post is sliding down the timeline, and the window to make the comment and have anyone read it, ever, is closing. Furthermore, while you were struggling with this idea in this post, 2 or 3 new posts have come up, and now you're well behind the crowd's attention span. Following this pattern, it's possible you may never be able to get one of your good ideas down when it matters, if at all. What to do?
If you're Phintastic or ToddReesingsTurfFacial or norbizness, you say "to hell with that" and stop finessing your comments altogether, favoring the opportunity to lay down a high volume of comments over the need to finesse each individual comment to its best possible version. You are now a grinder. This is bad. Most readers just start to ignore your comments, and the only people who ever respond to them or enjoy them are newbies or other grinders.
This standard sometimes seems unfair even to me, especially when applied to someone like Phintastic; he's put in his time, he's been around the block, maybe he's earned the right to not worry so much about whether his jokes are perfected. Why should he be disallowed from engaging in the fun of a good thread because he doesn't have time to reformat what he thinks is an already-funny concept? The real problem with grinding, as I see it, is that it lowers the standard for other commenters, and soon you've got an entire sub-set throwing up unadorned movie quotes and jpegs and sloppy, low-hanging-fruit puns, and not even attempting to submit true whoppers. It seems like that's where we are nowadays, but with the comment_ninja and FAILBOT coming back to life, perhaps we'll see a reversal of this trend.
Okay, enough of that. Jesus, I really got carried away there. Goooooooo DUAN!
Profiles in Commenting: MarkKelsosMigraine
Or: The Myriad Benefits Of An Olive-Oil Voice And Guinea Charm
Commenter Profile Link: MarkKelsosMigraine
Commenter Style: Dry, efficient, cultured, pop-culture-y, ambiguously meme-y
Today's topics for conversation are: control over whether a joke is funny and why; how much control the person making the joke has over those things; whether that matters when you're saying that that person is "funny"; and anyway what exactly it is that you're saying when you say that a person is "funny." I don't expect or really even intend to cover those topics fully or maybe even at all in this profile, but they are what I'm thinking about right now, and why MarkKelsosMigraine is our subject.
In this 2009 Commenter Of The Year article, in which MKM received an honorable mention, mention is made of his "bunch of swishy theatre references that have to be Googled," and these theatre/art/culture references are certainly what MKM is best known for as a Deadspin commenter. A comment like this one, referencing the epic Julie Taymor Broadway disaster Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark, is fairly representative of MKM's work in that area, in that it re-purposes the content of the article to crack a joke about something related to theatre.
But is that what the joke is really about? Is the joke here, "Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark is really dangerous for its performers"? I mean, sure, that's part of the joke, and the just-mild-enough-to-make-it-work exaggeration in the comment is plenty funny enough to stand on its own, given what anyone with a passing knowledge of the history of that troubled production brings to their reading of the joke. But there are two other key elements to the joke as well, like how a Space Shuttle launches with both its main engine and also two external rocket boosters that provide added propulsion (and here, if what you just thought was something along the lines that, in reality, the boosters provide the bulk of the thrust, while the main shuttle engine is the assistant, I say to you that the accuracy of that analogy is exactly what we are examining): the first is the seeming incongruity of a reference to a Broadway play, of all things, in the comment section of an article about football on a website dedicated to sports; the second, which adds more and more to the joke as your familiarity with MKM's body of work increases, is the there-he-goes-again-ness of MKM making yet another theatre reference in the comment section of an article about sports on a website dedicated to sports.
Who's responsible for that element of the joke? Does it exist only in the response of the reader? Because there's certainly nothing in the comment itself that contains any traceable hint of self-reference. And think of how much less funny it would be if MKM had structured the joke thusly:
"I can never get my paper airplanes to sail properly. Then again, I lost both my hands performing in Spiderman on Broadway," said MKM.
Or if he'd tailed the comment with a slashie along the lines of "/slinks back to Foxwoods Theatre." Or if he'd in any other way tipped his hand, acknowledged the unlikelihood of that joke, or compromised on the difficulty most Deadspin readers and commenters would have in fully comprehending it. (And here I must point out that, in the catalog of MKM theatre references on Deadspin, the one we're looking at is decidedly closer to the user-friendly end of the spectrum.) You know what it would have been? Lame.
And yet, the self-reference is present, and is not lame: it exists entirely in the ether, composed in equal parts of the work MKM did in establishing in longtime readers' minds that he's the guy who comfortably makes accurate and genuinely knowledgeable theatre references in the comment sections of articles about sports on a website dedicated to sports, and of the knowledge of that body of work that longtime readers bring to each new comment. A longtime reader might know more about that body of work than about Broadway - the reader might know nothing at all about Broadway - and still find the joke funny and admirable.
Think about what a trick that is. MKM has reached a point as a commenter where the impenetrability of a certain comment might actually work to that comment's favor, simply because of who wrote it. The first key to that trick, I think, is that it's abundantly clear that whoever MKM is in his non-Deadspin life, he's genuinely passionate about theatre, and not just poaching it for cheap obscurity. Otherwise his theatre references would come across as that worst and smarmiest of things: obscurity for its own sake. The second key is extreme discipline about when and how often to give any indication that he's aware that there's anything incongruous at all about making obscure (sometimes obscure-even-for-theatre) theatre references in the comment sections of articles about sports on a website dedicated to sports. He does this extremely rarely, and always with gentle, charming self-deprecation, and always when it's relevant - as in this comment, where his referencing his arts-and-culture ouvre was specifically germane to the topic of the post. And the comment was funny.
This dynamic in MKM's commenting (the funny theatre references getting funnier and funnier for the fact that he keeps making them) makes him possibly the meme-iest of all Deadspin commenters, despite the fact that, all told, theatre references certainly appear in less than half of his comments. Which brings us to that other recurring joke in MKM's body of work, which is the seemingly-utterly-random mentions of "olive-oil voice and guinea charm" (a phrase from The Godfather, in case you didn't know). Here's another joke that is A) funnier the more times you've seen it pop up, and B) only funny when MKM makes it, or when someone makes it who is clearly making an affectionate nod to MKM. Also like the theatre references, this one pops up far less frequently than you might think, given how indelibly it is associated with one of the site's most legendary contributors - but that scarcity is essential, here. Once in a blue moon, following no readily-apparent pattern, there it is.
Is that joke funny because the reference to The Godfather is funny? Probably not. The first reason it's funny, like with the theatre references, is the incongruity: the statement that, say, Paul Pasqualoni, or Jeremy Irons, possesses an olive-oil voice and guinea charm. But the second and more important mechanism for making it funny is one that only exists for people who've been around long enough to see the joke recur time and again, at odd intervals, presented completely unadorned by any overt indication of self-reference: the callback, the there-he-goes-again-ness of it.
MKM has some control over that, but not much, and what control he has is mostly through the discipline he exercises about when and how often to press that button. The life of that joke exists in the intersection of the number of times he's made it, and the number of times a particular reader has read it.
All of this talk of memes and self-reference and repetition might make MKM seem like a walking inside-joke, but he's not. This comment, which earned a mention in the Roundup, is just as representative of MKM's work as the swishiest theatre reference or the least-expected iteration of the "olive-oil voice and guinea charm" joke, in that it's well-constructed, sharp, and damn funny. But the structure that he has built over his time as a commenter, which allows him to make people laugh with the kinds of things that would get other commenters completely ignored, is one of the great accomplishments in the weird little world of Deadspin commenting.
Commenter Rating (out of five stars): «««««
Commenter Profile Link: MarkKelsosMigraine
Commenter Style: Dry, efficient, cultured, pop-culture-y, ambiguously meme-y
Today's topics for conversation are: control over whether a joke is funny and why; how much control the person making the joke has over those things; whether that matters when you're saying that that person is "funny"; and anyway what exactly it is that you're saying when you say that a person is "funny." I don't expect or really even intend to cover those topics fully or maybe even at all in this profile, but they are what I'm thinking about right now, and why MarkKelsosMigraine is our subject.
In this 2009 Commenter Of The Year article, in which MKM received an honorable mention, mention is made of his "bunch of swishy theatre references that have to be Googled," and these theatre/art/culture references are certainly what MKM is best known for as a Deadspin commenter. A comment like this one, referencing the epic Julie Taymor Broadway disaster Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark, is fairly representative of MKM's work in that area, in that it re-purposes the content of the article to crack a joke about something related to theatre.
But is that what the joke is really about? Is the joke here, "Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark is really dangerous for its performers"? I mean, sure, that's part of the joke, and the just-mild-enough-to-make-it-work exaggeration in the comment is plenty funny enough to stand on its own, given what anyone with a passing knowledge of the history of that troubled production brings to their reading of the joke. But there are two other key elements to the joke as well, like how a Space Shuttle launches with both its main engine and also two external rocket boosters that provide added propulsion (and here, if what you just thought was something along the lines that, in reality, the boosters provide the bulk of the thrust, while the main shuttle engine is the assistant, I say to you that the accuracy of that analogy is exactly what we are examining): the first is the seeming incongruity of a reference to a Broadway play, of all things, in the comment section of an article about football on a website dedicated to sports; the second, which adds more and more to the joke as your familiarity with MKM's body of work increases, is the there-he-goes-again-ness of MKM making yet another theatre reference in the comment section of an article about sports on a website dedicated to sports.
Who's responsible for that element of the joke? Does it exist only in the response of the reader? Because there's certainly nothing in the comment itself that contains any traceable hint of self-reference. And think of how much less funny it would be if MKM had structured the joke thusly:
"I can never get my paper airplanes to sail properly. Then again, I lost both my hands performing in Spiderman on Broadway," said MKM.
Or if he'd tailed the comment with a slashie along the lines of "/slinks back to Foxwoods Theatre." Or if he'd in any other way tipped his hand, acknowledged the unlikelihood of that joke, or compromised on the difficulty most Deadspin readers and commenters would have in fully comprehending it. (And here I must point out that, in the catalog of MKM theatre references on Deadspin, the one we're looking at is decidedly closer to the user-friendly end of the spectrum.) You know what it would have been? Lame.
And yet, the self-reference is present, and is not lame: it exists entirely in the ether, composed in equal parts of the work MKM did in establishing in longtime readers' minds that he's the guy who comfortably makes accurate and genuinely knowledgeable theatre references in the comment sections of articles about sports on a website dedicated to sports, and of the knowledge of that body of work that longtime readers bring to each new comment. A longtime reader might know more about that body of work than about Broadway - the reader might know nothing at all about Broadway - and still find the joke funny and admirable.
Think about what a trick that is. MKM has reached a point as a commenter where the impenetrability of a certain comment might actually work to that comment's favor, simply because of who wrote it. The first key to that trick, I think, is that it's abundantly clear that whoever MKM is in his non-Deadspin life, he's genuinely passionate about theatre, and not just poaching it for cheap obscurity. Otherwise his theatre references would come across as that worst and smarmiest of things: obscurity for its own sake. The second key is extreme discipline about when and how often to give any indication that he's aware that there's anything incongruous at all about making obscure (sometimes obscure-even-for-theatre) theatre references in the comment sections of articles about sports on a website dedicated to sports. He does this extremely rarely, and always with gentle, charming self-deprecation, and always when it's relevant - as in this comment, where his referencing his arts-and-culture ouvre was specifically germane to the topic of the post. And the comment was funny.
This dynamic in MKM's commenting (the funny theatre references getting funnier and funnier for the fact that he keeps making them) makes him possibly the meme-iest of all Deadspin commenters, despite the fact that, all told, theatre references certainly appear in less than half of his comments. Which brings us to that other recurring joke in MKM's body of work, which is the seemingly-utterly-random mentions of "olive-oil voice and guinea charm" (a phrase from The Godfather, in case you didn't know). Here's another joke that is A) funnier the more times you've seen it pop up, and B) only funny when MKM makes it, or when someone makes it who is clearly making an affectionate nod to MKM. Also like the theatre references, this one pops up far less frequently than you might think, given how indelibly it is associated with one of the site's most legendary contributors - but that scarcity is essential, here. Once in a blue moon, following no readily-apparent pattern, there it is.
Is that joke funny because the reference to The Godfather is funny? Probably not. The first reason it's funny, like with the theatre references, is the incongruity: the statement that, say, Paul Pasqualoni, or Jeremy Irons, possesses an olive-oil voice and guinea charm. But the second and more important mechanism for making it funny is one that only exists for people who've been around long enough to see the joke recur time and again, at odd intervals, presented completely unadorned by any overt indication of self-reference: the callback, the there-he-goes-again-ness of it.
MKM has some control over that, but not much, and what control he has is mostly through the discipline he exercises about when and how often to press that button. The life of that joke exists in the intersection of the number of times he's made it, and the number of times a particular reader has read it.
All of this talk of memes and self-reference and repetition might make MKM seem like a walking inside-joke, but he's not. This comment, which earned a mention in the Roundup, is just as representative of MKM's work as the swishiest theatre reference or the least-expected iteration of the "olive-oil voice and guinea charm" joke, in that it's well-constructed, sharp, and damn funny. But the structure that he has built over his time as a commenter, which allows him to make people laugh with the kinds of things that would get other commenters completely ignored, is one of the great accomplishments in the weird little world of Deadspin commenting.
Commenter Rating (out of five stars): «««««
Wednesday, April 6, 2011
Wednesday Roundup
Some favorites and very few duds from Wednesday's commenting.
Favorites, in no particular order:
Irregular contributor fat-leaveher had a nice day, first with this cleverly constructed comment in the Wake Up Deadspin post, and later with this shocking confession from Drew's Rant. For whatever reason, I almost always feel like an idiot for laughing at fat-leaveher's comments, but maybe that's just his particular niche. At any rate, I liked these two comments. So there.
Another guy who really had it today was our pal Gamboa Constrictor. Do I have a gay crush on Gamboa? Possibly. His offering in the Wake Up Deadspin post was wonderful, and it was done without any respelling, which I love. Later, I laughed loudly at his Weird Al joke in the Amazing Soccer Goal post. His current hot streak puts him up among the very best on Deadspin. Great job.
Another MBA favorite checked in with a few winners today; All Over But The Sharting first impressed me with an imaginative long-form contribution to the Brian Giles post, and later brought the funny with his at-first-glance-dense-but-then-suddenly-terrifically-silly joke in the Karen Sypher post. He just pushes out one solid, funny, happy comment after another.
Body by Bacardi got into the act today with a hilarious recontextualization in the Marty Turco post, and received some well-deserved applause. He hasn't been real active lately, but this was a bright, funny contribution, and one of the day's better comments (and it was a good day).
MarkKelsosMigraine struck again, this time with an awesome glimpse into Kentucky's legal justice system in the Karen Sypher post. I laughed quite a bit at this, and judging by the response, so did a great many other folks. Well done.
And finally, Steve U got back in the act with perhaps the day's best comment, this deliciously simple pun in the Kobe in China post. The crowd went wild over this one.
Total Fucking Duds
Two Duds today, the first from unstarred commenter ChuckHostetler'sMisspentYouth, also in the Kobe in China post. The comment_ninja jumped up and down on this one, and I'd say that's appropriate, although entire threads of comments have sprung up, to universal delight, around very similar humor, illustrating a point I made . . . whenever, about how important structure and timing and execution are to jokes that are potentially offensive. It's not the presence of a racial slur that makes this comment such a failure, it's the utter lack of care in delivery. There's no surprise in there, no guilty laugh, just an ugly, lifeless, unnecessary, unfunny attempt at a pun, right there in the middle of the sentence. The reader's first reaction is one of mild disgust. And I have not been offended by the long threads in other posts that have made use of one potentially offensive race/ethnicity/nationality pun after another.
The other dud came from starred (but otherwise forgettable) commenter blogsarefun, who violated the "be funny" rule with his sarcastic bitching and moaning in the Rotisserie Baseball post. For his efforts, his comment was grayed out by the ninja, and I'm all for that. The last thing in the world a Deadspin reader should see when they scroll down to the comments section of a very well-written, very funny post is a featured comment about how lame someone thinks it is. Furthermore, it's not for commenters to police the content of Deadspin posts. Not that there isn't room for criticism in the comments section; it should always be delivered as a joke. And blogsarefun has been around long enough to know better; in fact, the irony here is that, while referencing one part of the Commentist Manifesto, he ignored its first and most important rule of commenting; be funny, do not be not funny.
That's it! Go DUANing!
Favorites, in no particular order:
Irregular contributor fat-leaveher had a nice day, first with this cleverly constructed comment in the Wake Up Deadspin post, and later with this shocking confession from Drew's Rant. For whatever reason, I almost always feel like an idiot for laughing at fat-leaveher's comments, but maybe that's just his particular niche. At any rate, I liked these two comments. So there.
Another guy who really had it today was our pal Gamboa Constrictor. Do I have a gay crush on Gamboa? Possibly. His offering in the Wake Up Deadspin post was wonderful, and it was done without any respelling, which I love. Later, I laughed loudly at his Weird Al joke in the Amazing Soccer Goal post. His current hot streak puts him up among the very best on Deadspin. Great job.
Another MBA favorite checked in with a few winners today; All Over But The Sharting first impressed me with an imaginative long-form contribution to the Brian Giles post, and later brought the funny with his at-first-glance-dense-but-then-suddenly-terrifically-silly joke in the Karen Sypher post. He just pushes out one solid, funny, happy comment after another.
Body by Bacardi got into the act today with a hilarious recontextualization in the Marty Turco post, and received some well-deserved applause. He hasn't been real active lately, but this was a bright, funny contribution, and one of the day's better comments (and it was a good day).
MarkKelsosMigraine struck again, this time with an awesome glimpse into Kentucky's legal justice system in the Karen Sypher post. I laughed quite a bit at this, and judging by the response, so did a great many other folks. Well done.
And finally, Steve U got back in the act with perhaps the day's best comment, this deliciously simple pun in the Kobe in China post. The crowd went wild over this one.
Total Fucking Duds
Two Duds today, the first from unstarred commenter ChuckHostetler'sMisspentYouth, also in the Kobe in China post. The comment_ninja jumped up and down on this one, and I'd say that's appropriate, although entire threads of comments have sprung up, to universal delight, around very similar humor, illustrating a point I made . . . whenever, about how important structure and timing and execution are to jokes that are potentially offensive. It's not the presence of a racial slur that makes this comment such a failure, it's the utter lack of care in delivery. There's no surprise in there, no guilty laugh, just an ugly, lifeless, unnecessary, unfunny attempt at a pun, right there in the middle of the sentence. The reader's first reaction is one of mild disgust. And I have not been offended by the long threads in other posts that have made use of one potentially offensive race/ethnicity/nationality pun after another.
The other dud came from starred (but otherwise forgettable) commenter blogsarefun, who violated the "be funny" rule with his sarcastic bitching and moaning in the Rotisserie Baseball post. For his efforts, his comment was grayed out by the ninja, and I'm all for that. The last thing in the world a Deadspin reader should see when they scroll down to the comments section of a very well-written, very funny post is a featured comment about how lame someone thinks it is. Furthermore, it's not for commenters to police the content of Deadspin posts. Not that there isn't room for criticism in the comments section; it should always be delivered as a joke. And blogsarefun has been around long enough to know better; in fact, the irony here is that, while referencing one part of the Commentist Manifesto, he ignored its first and most important rule of commenting; be funny, do not be not funny.
That's it! Go DUANing!
Tuesday Roundup
Some favorites and very few duds from Tuesday's commenting.
Favorites, in no particular order:
MarkKelsosMigraine started things off with a funny Jane's Addiction joke in the Wake Up Deadspin post. For whatever reason, a clever, preposterous rethinking of a popular song or movie title, or a famous line of text, really does it for me.
In the Gambling on Wrestling post, Gamboa Constrictor used the simplest of comments to draw laughter and applause. I believe this comment has been made before, but at any rate, it was funny and appropriate and I liked it
All Over But The Sharting left a very funny, solidly-constructed Cinderella reference in the UConn Cinderella post. That joke is as cleanly tied as they get. Well done.
Total Fucking Duds:
Because there were very few favorites on Tuesday, I released myself to hammer a handful of especially crappy comments. No, I'm not going back to the bad times; this is a one-off event.
ToddReesingsTurfFacial was justifiably slapped by the comment_ninja for what is obviously a horrible comment in the Jim Nantz Dog Pun post. The ninja referred to it as meta-commenting, and I think that's an acceptable term, although it maybe could do more to reference the awfulness of the comment. For example, Scrap-Meta-Commenting. Yes. That's better. This kind of comment makes me crazy; clearly, there's an air of, "I know this is a bad comment, sorry" to his contribution. If you knew it was bad, why let it fly? Comments about commenting or commenting memes are dicey; commenters like Delonte, Interrupted once preempted bad comments all the time, and without much humor, and I always found that inappropriate. A comment that makes a hilarious joke by exploiting our common awareness of "low-hanging fruit" would be welcome, but this is not one of those. I don't write the commenter profiles, but I'll say this about TRTF: he has really fallen off lately. A while back, he was a grinder; he dropped comments in every thread, and seemed willing to torture the shit out of a post's content in order to try to impress readers. There was a certain frenzied genius to his commenting style, even though he was conspicuously not always funny and wound up losing his star. Nowadays, he's back to his grinding ways, but now he's more or less carpet-bombing posts with lazy, half-formed, almost aggressively unworthy comments, and this was obviously a low-point in that trend. I'd take the old 550ft. Home Run or Strike Out TRTF over this new, lazy, obnoxious version.
Next up is breathing Deadspin meme Phintastic, a commenting enigma if ever there was one, and his mind-bogglingly worthless contribution to the Greece Fire post. That is the commenting equivalent of an audible, smelly fart in a crowded elevator. The joke there, as far as I can tell, is that "on fire" can be translated into another language. That the game was played in Greece and the fire started by Greek fans is, according to Phintastic, irrelevant. Maybe the fact that the opposition was Barcelona makes the use of the Spanish language appropriate. That can't possibly satisfy anyone's criteria for a good, funny comment. To me, the choice of language seems random, and is therefore irrelevant, which means that Phintastic's comment says, "On Fire." That's not a joke or a comment, that's the observation of a 2 year old.
And finally, there's this. This is exactly the kind of thing I was trying to avoid when I swore off more extensive Duds sections. I don't know why this deserves any special mention, other than that I think I developed an aneurysm upon reading it.
Look, the ninja's most important job, as I see it, is to police the featured comments, because they are the outward representation of Deadspin's commentariat and a significant part of the actual content provided by Deadspin. But the very next order of business has to be getting guys like shuttledik out of the picture altogether. Yes, he often attempts humor, but he's not even thorough enough to check for obvious spelling errors in his comments, and I don't think he's had a single comment promoted ever. He's not contributing to Deadspin's comments, he's trolling. His output represents probably 15% or more of the truly terrible comments made on Deadspin. Bust out the sad trombone and get rid of this guy, already.
Alrighty, guys. Look for a Wednesday Roundup in the regular Wednesday evening time-slot, and as always, have a lovely DUAN.
Favorites, in no particular order:
MarkKelsosMigraine started things off with a funny Jane's Addiction joke in the Wake Up Deadspin post. For whatever reason, a clever, preposterous rethinking of a popular song or movie title, or a famous line of text, really does it for me.
In the Gambling on Wrestling post, Gamboa Constrictor used the simplest of comments to draw laughter and applause. I believe this comment has been made before, but at any rate, it was funny and appropriate and I liked it
All Over But The Sharting left a very funny, solidly-constructed Cinderella reference in the UConn Cinderella post. That joke is as cleanly tied as they get. Well done.
Total Fucking Duds:
Because there were very few favorites on Tuesday, I released myself to hammer a handful of especially crappy comments. No, I'm not going back to the bad times; this is a one-off event.
ToddReesingsTurfFacial was justifiably slapped by the comment_ninja for what is obviously a horrible comment in the Jim Nantz Dog Pun post. The ninja referred to it as meta-commenting, and I think that's an acceptable term, although it maybe could do more to reference the awfulness of the comment. For example, Scrap-Meta-Commenting. Yes. That's better. This kind of comment makes me crazy; clearly, there's an air of, "I know this is a bad comment, sorry" to his contribution. If you knew it was bad, why let it fly? Comments about commenting or commenting memes are dicey; commenters like Delonte, Interrupted once preempted bad comments all the time, and without much humor, and I always found that inappropriate. A comment that makes a hilarious joke by exploiting our common awareness of "low-hanging fruit" would be welcome, but this is not one of those. I don't write the commenter profiles, but I'll say this about TRTF: he has really fallen off lately. A while back, he was a grinder; he dropped comments in every thread, and seemed willing to torture the shit out of a post's content in order to try to impress readers. There was a certain frenzied genius to his commenting style, even though he was conspicuously not always funny and wound up losing his star. Nowadays, he's back to his grinding ways, but now he's more or less carpet-bombing posts with lazy, half-formed, almost aggressively unworthy comments, and this was obviously a low-point in that trend. I'd take the old 550ft. Home Run or Strike Out TRTF over this new, lazy, obnoxious version.
Next up is breathing Deadspin meme Phintastic, a commenting enigma if ever there was one, and his mind-bogglingly worthless contribution to the Greece Fire post. That is the commenting equivalent of an audible, smelly fart in a crowded elevator. The joke there, as far as I can tell, is that "on fire" can be translated into another language. That the game was played in Greece and the fire started by Greek fans is, according to Phintastic, irrelevant. Maybe the fact that the opposition was Barcelona makes the use of the Spanish language appropriate. That can't possibly satisfy anyone's criteria for a good, funny comment. To me, the choice of language seems random, and is therefore irrelevant, which means that Phintastic's comment says, "On Fire." That's not a joke or a comment, that's the observation of a 2 year old.
And finally, there's this. This is exactly the kind of thing I was trying to avoid when I swore off more extensive Duds sections. I don't know why this deserves any special mention, other than that I think I developed an aneurysm upon reading it.
Look, the ninja's most important job, as I see it, is to police the featured comments, because they are the outward representation of Deadspin's commentariat and a significant part of the actual content provided by Deadspin. But the very next order of business has to be getting guys like shuttledik out of the picture altogether. Yes, he often attempts humor, but he's not even thorough enough to check for obvious spelling errors in his comments, and I don't think he's had a single comment promoted ever. He's not contributing to Deadspin's comments, he's trolling. His output represents probably 15% or more of the truly terrible comments made on Deadspin. Bust out the sad trombone and get rid of this guy, already.
Alrighty, guys. Look for a Wednesday Roundup in the regular Wednesday evening time-slot, and as always, have a lovely DUAN.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Monday Roundup
Some favorites and very few duds from Monday's commenting.
Favorites, in no particular order:
Same Sad Echo had a nice day, first checking in with a very simple, very funny contribution to the UConn Dean's List post Monday morning, then making me laugh with a few lines of Muppets dialogue in this afternoon's Goalie Lawsuit post. What can I say? I'm a huge sucker for cartoon/Muppets references (yes, I'm serious).
Mad Bastard's All favorite Gamboa Constrictor made me laugh with an uncomfortable confession in the Churro Blowjob post.
Deadspin powerhouse David Hume made a rare appearance with this ingenious (and hilarious) (and true) comment in the Churro Blowjob post. Deadspin could use a hell of a lot more of him right now.
The possibility that MarkKelsosMigraine might be returning to regular commenting makes me positively giddy. Two of his comments made me guffaw loudly today; first this, in the Churro Blowjob post, and especially this, in the Viagra post. I'm willing to concede, however, that at least part of the joy and humor of that second one is that it is, of course, coming from MarkKelsosMigraine. It's a funny joke, absolutely, but who else makes that joke?
And finally, Cyrus_the_virus drew a giggle with a very simple, straight-forward pun in the Viagra post. That's good work, there. He's still finding his legs as a starred commenter, but he's capable of some very good jokes.
Total Fucking Duds
As promised, we cut down dramatically on the Duds today. In fact, there's only one, and it came, not from shuttledik or sacoplenty or priestinacloset1 or Paolo.Lex (though he really fucking tried) or Billy Clyde Puckett (he really wanted it, too), but from starred commenter Armen Tamzarian, for an indefensibly lame, vulgar, sophomoric deflect-a-joke in the Wayne Rooney Suspension post. I've chosen to highlight this awful comment for a number of reasons; first of all, it illustrates at least two previously-unaccounted-for types of bad comments: 1. the Deflect-a-Joke, in which a commenter does not actually make the joke himself, but says something to the effect of "there's a [blank] joke in there somewhere", which is useless and vacuous and lazy; and 2. the Obfuscated Bigotry joke, in which someone uses clever wordplay to try to cover up the fact that their joke boils down to "[insert minority group] is an easy target for offensive humor". This offering from Armen Tamzarian falls into both categories, and is well beneath a featured commenter.
Secondly, I've singled out this comment because FAILBOT was good enough to give him a very light but very ominous warning about it. That's wonderful to see. It's one thing for unstarred commenters to have their bad crap shipped off to #somethingaboutbanningsomeoneisland or whatever, but the site benefits much more from starred commenters having their lazy offerings checked, as it sends a broad, visible message to the entire commentariat and explicitly discourages lazy commenting.
Hey, have a wonderful DUAN.
Favorites, in no particular order:
Same Sad Echo had a nice day, first checking in with a very simple, very funny contribution to the UConn Dean's List post Monday morning, then making me laugh with a few lines of Muppets dialogue in this afternoon's Goalie Lawsuit post. What can I say? I'm a huge sucker for cartoon/Muppets references (yes, I'm serious).
Mad Bastard's All favorite Gamboa Constrictor made me laugh with an uncomfortable confession in the Churro Blowjob post.
Deadspin powerhouse David Hume made a rare appearance with this ingenious (and hilarious) (and true) comment in the Churro Blowjob post. Deadspin could use a hell of a lot more of him right now.
The possibility that MarkKelsosMigraine might be returning to regular commenting makes me positively giddy. Two of his comments made me guffaw loudly today; first this, in the Churro Blowjob post, and especially this, in the Viagra post. I'm willing to concede, however, that at least part of the joy and humor of that second one is that it is, of course, coming from MarkKelsosMigraine. It's a funny joke, absolutely, but who else makes that joke?
And finally, Cyrus_the_virus drew a giggle with a very simple, straight-forward pun in the Viagra post. That's good work, there. He's still finding his legs as a starred commenter, but he's capable of some very good jokes.
Total Fucking Duds
As promised, we cut down dramatically on the Duds today. In fact, there's only one, and it came, not from shuttledik or sacoplenty or priestinacloset1 or Paolo.Lex (though he really fucking tried) or Billy Clyde Puckett (he really wanted it, too), but from starred commenter Armen Tamzarian, for an indefensibly lame, vulgar, sophomoric deflect-a-joke in the Wayne Rooney Suspension post. I've chosen to highlight this awful comment for a number of reasons; first of all, it illustrates at least two previously-unaccounted-for types of bad comments: 1. the Deflect-a-Joke, in which a commenter does not actually make the joke himself, but says something to the effect of "there's a [blank] joke in there somewhere", which is useless and vacuous and lazy; and 2. the Obfuscated Bigotry joke, in which someone uses clever wordplay to try to cover up the fact that their joke boils down to "[insert minority group] is an easy target for offensive humor". This offering from Armen Tamzarian falls into both categories, and is well beneath a featured commenter.
Secondly, I've singled out this comment because FAILBOT was good enough to give him a very light but very ominous warning about it. That's wonderful to see. It's one thing for unstarred commenters to have their bad crap shipped off to #somethingaboutbanningsomeoneisland or whatever, but the site benefits much more from starred commenters having their lazy offerings checked, as it sends a broad, visible message to the entire commentariat and explicitly discourages lazy commenting.
Hey, have a wonderful DUAN.
The Exodus, Duly Noted
This past Saturday night there was a very interesting DUAN conversation about the state of Deadspin commenting, in which several prominent commenters (Steve U, Eddie Murray Sparkles, Bevraj of Choice, Gamboa Constrictor, All Over But The Sharting, and others - including a surprise appearance by ClueHeywood, one of the original gangstas of the Deadspin Commentariat) expressed their frustration at the ongoing technical problems in the commenting system, the radio silence on that front from Gawker/Deadspin's powers-that-be, and the continued exodus of quality, longtime commenters from the site.
The important things to notice from that conversation are: the palpable frustration and disappointment being expressed by some of the site's top contributors, including guys like EMS and Sharting who've until recently been fairly upbeat and positive whenever the topic of the redesign comes up; very prominent commenters like EMS describing the current state of the site as a "wasteland" and openly talking about the poor overall quality of commenting at present; and Steve U and others talking about a total death of commenting as though it is a foregone conclusion. No one outside of Gawker's offices can say whether those things put a shiver into the site's movers and shakers; as for me, as someone who is enough of a fan of that site's comment threads that he went and started a blog about it, I'm depressed.
And if that conversation didn't do it for you, how about last night's retirement-from-commenting by UweBollocks, one of Deadspin's most beloved contributors? People, that is a heartbreaker, and at least as ominous a portent of the future of the site's commenting section as the unannounced disappearance of all-time greats like AzureTexan, Lionel Osbourne, Theodore Donald Kerabatsos, and others (leaving aside guys like David Hume and MarkKelsosMigraine, who still show up from time to time, but at only a minute fraction of their former frequency). Uwe was one of the site's most approachable and easily-digestible commenting voices, and I'd guess that a great many current commenters joined the site because of funny, silly, user-friendly guys like him.
Now there's talk (in the thread attached to Uwe's retirement) of commenters staying away deliberately, as an act of protest - which might, in the sense that it holds out the possibility for a mass return someday, seem preferable to the slow bleed of contributors disappearing as commenting simply ceases to be enjoyable for them, but still means a lot less of the funniest people on the internet all being funny in the same place at the same time, which sucks for those of us whose primary reason for visiting the site is the comments.
My intention here is not to bitch about Deadspin's redesign - Lord knows the commenters have done enough of that over the past couple of months - but rather to mourn what certainly appears to be the slow death of what has been one of the best things about the entire internet. I don't want to jump the gun too much - just today (it's 11:40am ET as I write this), we've already seen multiple comments from MKM, Hume, and don't-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac, plus an appearance by commenting legend ArkansasFred; - and nobody hopes for a rebound more than I do, but it's hard to escape the feeling that something has been irreparably broken. And anyway, I won't believe things are truly fixed until we've either seen the return of people like AzureTexan and UweBollocks, or new additions to the commentariat have truly filled the empty space left behind by those who've abandoned the site. Neither of those things have happened, and based on the crop of unstarred folks these days, Option B doesn't look likely.
As at least a couple of commenters noted in that Saturday night conversation, it would be great if someone from among Gawker Media's or Deadspin's staff would respect the readership and the commentariat enough to at least put out a statement on one of the sites - even if, as Eddie Murray Sparkles noted, it was just a statement to the effect that site viewership and ad revenue are up since the redesign, so concerns about bugs in the commenting system are not a priority, and commenters can go get fucked if they don't like it. Something. Anything. As things stand now, the radio silence unambiguously sends the message that nobody gives a shit one way or another.
Anyway, since we're a blog dedicated to the Deadspin Commentariat, I figured it would be silly to continue doing what we're doing without acknowledging the biggest thing going on in that community these days. Things don't look so good right now. And it's notable as hell that, as of this writing, Steve U, who typically comments on damn near every single post in any given day, has not commented once yet today.
Carry on.
The important things to notice from that conversation are: the palpable frustration and disappointment being expressed by some of the site's top contributors, including guys like EMS and Sharting who've until recently been fairly upbeat and positive whenever the topic of the redesign comes up; very prominent commenters like EMS describing the current state of the site as a "wasteland" and openly talking about the poor overall quality of commenting at present; and Steve U and others talking about a total death of commenting as though it is a foregone conclusion. No one outside of Gawker's offices can say whether those things put a shiver into the site's movers and shakers; as for me, as someone who is enough of a fan of that site's comment threads that he went and started a blog about it, I'm depressed.
And if that conversation didn't do it for you, how about last night's retirement-from-commenting by UweBollocks, one of Deadspin's most beloved contributors? People, that is a heartbreaker, and at least as ominous a portent of the future of the site's commenting section as the unannounced disappearance of all-time greats like AzureTexan, Lionel Osbourne, Theodore Donald Kerabatsos, and others (leaving aside guys like David Hume and MarkKelsosMigraine, who still show up from time to time, but at only a minute fraction of their former frequency). Uwe was one of the site's most approachable and easily-digestible commenting voices, and I'd guess that a great many current commenters joined the site because of funny, silly, user-friendly guys like him.
Now there's talk (in the thread attached to Uwe's retirement) of commenters staying away deliberately, as an act of protest - which might, in the sense that it holds out the possibility for a mass return someday, seem preferable to the slow bleed of contributors disappearing as commenting simply ceases to be enjoyable for them, but still means a lot less of the funniest people on the internet all being funny in the same place at the same time, which sucks for those of us whose primary reason for visiting the site is the comments.
My intention here is not to bitch about Deadspin's redesign - Lord knows the commenters have done enough of that over the past couple of months - but rather to mourn what certainly appears to be the slow death of what has been one of the best things about the entire internet. I don't want to jump the gun too much - just today (it's 11:40am ET as I write this), we've already seen multiple comments from MKM, Hume, and don't-forget-where-you-came-from-cheese mac, plus an appearance by commenting legend ArkansasFred; - and nobody hopes for a rebound more than I do, but it's hard to escape the feeling that something has been irreparably broken. And anyway, I won't believe things are truly fixed until we've either seen the return of people like AzureTexan and UweBollocks, or new additions to the commentariat have truly filled the empty space left behind by those who've abandoned the site. Neither of those things have happened, and based on the crop of unstarred folks these days, Option B doesn't look likely.
As at least a couple of commenters noted in that Saturday night conversation, it would be great if someone from among Gawker Media's or Deadspin's staff would respect the readership and the commentariat enough to at least put out a statement on one of the sites - even if, as Eddie Murray Sparkles noted, it was just a statement to the effect that site viewership and ad revenue are up since the redesign, so concerns about bugs in the commenting system are not a priority, and commenters can go get fucked if they don't like it. Something. Anything. As things stand now, the radio silence unambiguously sends the message that nobody gives a shit one way or another.
Anyway, since we're a blog dedicated to the Deadspin Commentariat, I figured it would be silly to continue doing what we're doing without acknowledging the biggest thing going on in that community these days. Things don't look so good right now. And it's notable as hell that, as of this writing, Steve U, who typically comments on damn near every single post in any given day, has not commented once yet today.
Carry on.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
